Fionn MacCool’s

Reviews

• Garrik K.

  star star star star star 3 June 2026

  I did not expect a place like this at the Four Points Sheraton.  It's a nice motel/hotel, but this place is like somewhere you might go in downtown.
  
  First night (Thursday), had a Fionn's Power bowl with salmon and was so pleasantly surprised.  Did not expect a delicious healthy option like this at an Irish Pub.  
  
  The live music was absolutely awesome.  It was a one-man show.  Guy was playing really good classic rock with a headless guitar.  He looked like the typical Canadian uncle but sounded like Don Henley.  Deeply receding hairline with number 4 buzz cut, brushed up and spiked to the sky, all perfectly even length.  Almost like a receding flat-top.  He could rock though!  Maybe his brushed up crew cut was the result of jamming so vigorously that he built up static electricity all the way up to his head.  He was too good though.  Like too good to be playing at a pub on Wednesday night.  It made me wonder if he was playing the music.... or perhaps was the music possessing him and playing THROUGH him?  As if by some miracle there was a role reversal, and electric guitar became the master, and he the slave? The brushed up fuzzy hair seemed evident that the electricity overcame him, and he was just a passenger on a wild ride.
  
  Second night was quite busy.  Watched the Toronto Maple Leafs beat the Las Vegas Knights.  I had a toffee pudding with vanilla and water.  That right there says it all.  It's an Irish sports bar, but still cosmopolitan enough that I could order a sissy-ass toffee pudding with vanilla and not worry that I'm going to get beat up.

• Brandy W.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 31 May 2026

  Mediocre food complimented with HORRIBLE customer service.
  Added item on our bill that we never ordered. After asking the waitress to fix the bill, we noticed being overcharged for one of the daily special item on the 'fixed' bill. Talked to our waitress first and she insisted that is the right price until we requested to see the menu. We LITERALLY had to point her the item price to convince her to fix it.
  Neither did the floor manager or our waitress bothered to apologize the entire time like it was our fault to correct them. Since when did the customers have to double check the bill to make sure they will not get scammed?

• Kristin R.

  star star star star star 28 May 2026

  Enjoyed late night eats and breakfast the following day. Loved that we could get the full menu at 10 pm and enjoyed the acoustic music. One of my companions said the chicken pot pie was dry, but my mini Yorkies were excellent, as was the sticky toffee pudding that all three of us ordered - no sharing for us! It was too good.
  Breakfast standards - eggs and toast, French toast and eggs Benedict- all served with home fries were great, with the exception of the bacon - which wasn't as crisp as requested.
  Atmosphere was of a neighborhood Irish pub - they pulled it off, considering this was a hotel bar.

• Jem C.

  star star star star star 15 May 2026

  Quality of Food (5/5)
  
  Everything was made-to-order with accommodations / tweaks needed for us.  This may be a pub serving alcoholic drinks and deep-fried foods but surprisingly the healthier and heartier food were amazing too.  Everything was plated pretty and tasted great too!  The desserts were priced very affordable and my group was able to share it.  
  
  I'd recommend the brownie because it was pure chocolate bliss!
  
  Price (4/5)
  
  I was expecting it to cost more since it was attached to the hotel but was reasonably price.  I came with a large group (over 10+) and they didn't charge us the traditional group fee most restaurants impose on the bill.  
  
  Customer Service (5/5)
  
  Came here after the crazy disorganized nerd convention known as Anime North.  Waitress was very accommodating and attentive to our need esp. allergy alerts.  She notified us that the kitchen staff will ensure no cross-contamination would be occur which was greatly appreciated.
  
  Environment / Ambiance (5/5)
  
  Loved the environment.  Very spacious and the chairs / booths were clean and comfortable!  I'm used to pubs with that "grimy" feeling so it was a surprise for me.  
  
  It should be noted, we went during dinner time and it was not busy at all.  Usually, I would assume it's not busy because the food wasn't good but I believe given it's a Sun night where probably most hotel guests have checked out the morning of, it was fine by me.  Pubs and main-stream restaurants can get too loud for me.
  
  Overall (5/5)
  
  Highly recommended and will most likely visit this pub again next year for the convention!